How carbon giant China is eclipsing Britain's zero push

Perhaps Rishi Sunak didn't expect Sir Tony Blair to become a zero network skeptic.

At the height of the Tory battle over the UK's carbon cut targets and the policies used to achieve them, the last Labor leader to win the general election has voiced caution. He suggested that the reduction of the UK's contribution to global CO2 emissions raises new questions in the fight against climate change.

“This is the biggest global problem, right, and the UK must play its part in this. But frankly, some of it will be less related to UK emissions. I mean, China's emissions growth in one year will surpass all the UK's emissions in a year,» the former Labor leader told the magazine.

He said «it shouldn't be» an excuse to cut emissions, but added that reducing our own carbon shouldn't be the focus:

«Don't ask us to do something huge if, honestly to put it bluntly, everything we do in Britain will not really do any good.” influences climate change,” he said.

So, how are UK emissions different from China?

First of all, the main emissions.

2907 Emissions in China

As one of the early leaders of the industrial revolution and a coal-fired miracle worker, the UK produced more CO2 emissions than China until the 1950s and completely overtook it in the 1970s.

At the top of the world's workshop in the 1990s and 2000s, China produced six times as much CO2 as the UK in 2000, according to Our World in Data, an increase of more than 16 times that of the UK in 2010, and 33 times by 2021.

This is partly due to the decline in emissions in the UK — emissions in the UK have fallen by two-fifths since the start of the new millennium — but mainly due to increased production in China.

How fast are emissions growing in the country?

p>

Sir Tony was right when he noted that in some years China's annual emissions growth did indeed exceed the UK's total CO2 emissions.

This was last true in 2021 — 2022 data year is not correct. still available — and in 2019, before Covid perpetuated disruptions.

2,907 One-year growth exceeds UK total

For decades, China's emissions were higher than the UK's, not because it reached the same level of prosperity — roughly speaking, getting rich for the long haul meant producing more emissions, but because the population of China was larger. /p>

However, about a decade ago, per capita emissions in China also exceeded those in the UK, despite the fact that the country was significantly poorer than the UK.

In 2021, UK emissions per capita were 5.2 tons, not counting Covid-stricken 2020, the lowest level since the 1850s. China, by contrast, hit a record high of just over 8 tonnes per capita.

2907 Emissions soar as China grows

This is partly because the UK is expanding its service sector while China is exporting more manufactured goods to China. rest of the world. However, this points to an extremely carbon-intensive economy that is heading in the wrong direction.

Then there is a reason for emissions. The UK, once a coal mining champion, has all but phased out highly polluting fuels. Coal emissions have been declining since the 1950s and are now at levels last seen in the late 18th century.

China is moving in a different direction.

While UK coal emissions have fallen to around 24 million tons a year, China's emissions have risen to nearly 8 billion, about 20 times the peak annual amount mined by the UK in the last century, and frighteningly high by any measure.< /p> 2907 Rapid coal pollution

Besides focusing on emissions, what does Sir Tony think the UK should focus on?

Instead, he suggests that the UK should use its economic advantage: finance.

This is also different from the proposals that the UK should try to beat in competition with the US and the EU, allocating huge subsidies for the creation of green industries to catch up with China.

«Number one problem today — and this is where Britain could play a role — how do you finance the energy transition?» he asked.

“Because, in fact, emissions in developed countries are decreasing, while in developing countries they are increasing. These countries need to grow, so how are you funding the transition? Second, how are you accelerating the technology?”

When it comes to the potential benefits of the UK in greening the global economy, climate scientists suspect that the UK’s financial advantage could be valuable, but only when combined with the need to cut emissions further .

“We have all these comparative advantages and we are squandering them a bit,” says environmental policy researcher Laurie Laybourne.

“The UK is reducing its emissions, whether they are more or less than China, is a way to focus our agenda on making the most of the amazing opportunities we have in the UK, like our financial services, and how amazingly good we are at inventing things.”

Now he is apprehensive that China has realized that it is becoming an economic winner, even as it continues to burn fossil fuels. He believes renewables will fuel China's growth as coal led to the industrial revolution in the UK and oil ensured American hegemony in the 20th century, he suggests.

«Big win in key energy sources of the day is a big economic win,” he says.

“China is doing it with renewable energy.”