Conservatives should abandon a system that “seems like the taxman is breathing down our necks from cradle to grave,” said Ranil Jayawardena.
Speaking at the Center for Policy Research think tank last week, with Liz Truss cheering from the sidelines, the chairman of the influential Conservative Growth Group said: “We need to believe in tax cuts because it helps hard-working families should be at the center of the Conservatives' plan for our great nation.” ”.
However, Jeremy Hunt had a completely different opinion. Just hours after his speech, Jayawardena told a crowded auditorium of high-ranking bankers that fighting inflation was more important than cutting taxes.
“Providing sound money is our main goal,” the chancellor insisted at the annual dinner at the mansion, arguing that “reducing inflation puts more money in people's pockets than any tax cut.”
The Tory Party is increasingly divided over taxes, with two factions centered around the last two prime ministers.
Those in favor of cuts rally around Truss, who used her short time as prime minister to announce about the ill-fated cuts. This camp argues that the burden on businesses and families needs to be reduced in order for the economy to grow again.
Inflation in 2306 in the UK compared
“There is a great danger that we will fall into a vicious circle where we will have a large public debt due to low growth,” says Tom Clougherty of the CPS think tank founded by Margaret Thatcher.
>
“From Because of this, we cannot reduce taxes, and the tax burden continues to grow. And that in itself is pushing for growth. Thus, the budget deficit becomes larger, not smaller, and the prospect of tax cuts is further pushed into the future.
“I think both economically and politically they can [cut taxes] and they really need to think about what they can do in the time they have left to improve things.”
However, the current prime minister, Rishi Sunak, and his chancellor believe that tax cuts will only exacerbate the UK's inflationary crisis.
Though Sunak has hinted at a possible cut before next year's elections, hopes are waning as the government struggles to stop the skyrocketing prices and the prime minister's five promises are being questioned.
Discussions about a promise to abolish the tax are said on the inheritance “live” in Downing Street. However, this policy will only be a manifesto to be adopted after the next election and will depend on controlling inflation.
Paul Dales, chief economist at Capital Economics in the UK, says: “Recent events have likely reduced the budget buffer and reduced the likelihood of significant fiscal easing ahead of the next election.”
Official data released this week is expected to show headline inflation eased to 8.3% year-on-year through June from 8.7% in May. However, it will still be well above the BoE's 2% target.
Inflation has also been higher than expected on a monthly basis since March, raising the possibility of another overshoot in June.
Persistently high inflation has forced the Bank to raise interest rates to the highest level since 2008, with markets predicting that the benchmark could peak at 6%.
Rising rates have led to a sharp increase in the cost of servicing UK debt by £2.5 trillion.
Dales says the sharp rise in borrowing costs could leave the government as little as £2.5bn if it wants to meet an already vague goal of securing debt falling within five years. In March, the military budget reserve had already fallen to a record low of £6 billion.
A sustained period of higher interest rates, combined with higher stocks of post-pandemic debt, will push interest rates on debt from 4% of gross domestic product (GDP) today to an all-time high of 13% of GDP by the middle. -2070s, the Office of Fiscal Responsibility warned last week. In today's money, that's £325 billion. Debt could also rise to 300% of GDP as the size of the economy is negligible compared to the country's total borrowing.
Sunak's promise to halve inflation from 10.7% by the end of the year now looks like serious doubt. The promise was made when the Bank of England predicted that the rate would fall quickly.
However, inflation is currently not expected to return to the Bank's 2% target until early 2025. The International Monetary Fund believes that this may happen even later.
It is against this backdrop that Hunt and Sunak decided on any short-term tax cuts.
Lord Lamont backs the government's position, saying that lowering inflation “should be a prerequisite first and foremost. He needs to be hit hard on the head.”
He notes that the government is expected to borrow £131bn this year to close the gap between taxes and spending. Tax cuts will add to this heap and further stretch public finances.
“I think you can only lower taxes when the public finances are stronger,” says the former chancellor. “We still have a very loose fiscal policy and a big deficit. And the ratio of debt to GDP is somewhere around 100%. I just don't understand how they can do something drastic on the tax front for quite some time.”
Ranil Jayawardena ( right) was Minister for the Environment under Liz Truss. Photo: Leon Neal/Getty Images Europe
Jayewardena, who was Truss's environment minister, agrees that controlling inflation is important but believes it is not the government's job. .
“I believe in sound money,” he says. “The trouble is that the Bank of England has been printing money since 2009. This is where we have lost the concept of sound money.
“The Chancellor is absolutely right that we should bring inflation down. The main problem is how we help hardworking families who are currently experiencing difficulties. That's why we're putting forward ideas for targeted tax reform.”
He's pushing for further reforms in childcare that will allow families to keep more of their hard-earned money, rather than increasing the subsidies offered. Mr Hunt.
The conservative growth group, which is growing steadily to 60 members, will propose further housing, planning and regulatory reforms in the coming months, including changes to unpopular taxes like stamp duty. Even the IMF has warned that the home sales levy creates distortions.
Members are also promoting the idea of abolishing the inheritance tax, although there have been no direct negotiations with Downing Street.
Jayawardena. says their thoughtful reforms are designed to spur growth without hurting the budget. Faster growth will also help reduce debt relative to the size of our economy.
“I still believe that the Conservative Party is the lower tax party, and we will prove it in the coming months,” he says. “I believe that Jeremy and Rishi want it. And that's why we're coming up with ideas to help them consider new ways to do it, rather than just resorting to a general policy, “penny cut from income tax.”
1605 tax freeze
Lord Lamont believes that when it can afford it, the government should lower the corporate tax rate and solve the problem of the tax burden by adjusting the tax framework in line with inflation. The OBR calculated that Hunt's decision to freeze income tax thresholds until 2028 was equivalent to 4d income tax.
The window for action may be closing. The Conservatives are bracing for defeat in the next election, and pundits are already comparing the pending vote to Tony Blair's landslide victory in 1997 for the Labor Party.
Hunt doesn't hesitate. He's betting that Labor's longstanding reputation for spending and taxes will be remembered for more than Truss's ill-advised pursuit of growth.
“Voters want to know their money and jobs are safe,” says one Treasury source. “When you have uncertain times, the calculus is very different from when you have good times. And that's probably the biggest difference.
“In 1997 it was safe to go with Labor because the economy was booming and Tony Blair was far more supportive of capitalism than Keir Starmer.”
However, if the government suffers a crushing defeat, the tax debate within the Conservative Party threatens to turn into a bitter division.
Jayawardena downplays the threat, saying, “I don't believe it for one second. The Conservative Party is the broad church. We don't believe in a party of command or control, as socialists do.”
But he acknowledges that the Tories must do more if they have any hope of ruling the country for five more years.
“We have to demonstrate how we're going to help people keep more money in their back pocket. Now and in the future.”
Recent Comments