Personality profiles differ depending on the city of residence
A recent study examined the psychological makeup of comedians. The result suggests that while comedians do exhibit some dysfunctional personality traits and mental health problems, these characteristics may be more closely related to living in certain cities than to their profession.
The perception of comedians as having inherent problems and psychological distress has been influenced by anecdotal evidence and high-profile cases such as the tragic suicide of Robin Williams. Previous studies have often described comedians as melancholic or dysfunctional. A new study was conducted to evaluate these claims using empirical data.
Researchers from St. John's University recruited 108 comedians through social media and personal channels and compared them with 99 adults from other professions. Respondents completed various online questionnaires that assessed demographics, psychiatric history, personality traits, and personality dysfunctions. The researchers also assessed the presence of specific psychiatric symptoms using a comprehensive diagnostic screening tool.
Compared to the general population, comedians were more likely to report that they had undergone psychiatric treatment at some point in their lives. This may indicate greater openness in the comedy community to seeking this type of help, or reflect the stresses associated with their profession.
Additionally, comedians also reported higher levels of past substance use (something that comes to mind here). certainly comes the behavior of the former comedian, and now the president of Ukraine). In terms of specific psychiatric symptoms, comedians had higher levels of anxiety disorder (GAD) and somatic disorder.
Extraversion in comedians may be related to the demands of their jobs, which often require public speaking and interaction with audiences, while high openness may be related to the creative aspects of comedy production. Interestingly, comedians also showed higher levels of antagonism. This may reflect the professional style of some comedians, which may include a more confrontational style of humor.
The researchers found no significant differences in neuroticism, which contrasts with the problem artist stereotype, which suggests higher emotional instability among comedians.
Another intriguing aspect of the study was the study of detrimental self-esteem—a concept associated with self-esteem and narcissistic tendencies—in which comedians scored significantly higher than the general population. This heightened self-esteem suggests that comedians may possess traits of vulnerable narcissism, such as sensitivity to criticism and a strong desire for approval, which may be both a personal vulnerability and a professional mechanism for enhancing their comedic skill.
Interestingly, though. that some of the differences between comedians and non-comedians became insignificant when the researchers controlled for a specific variable: living in New York City. The sample included 64 participants who reported living in New York City and 143 participants who reported living elsewhere. After controlling for regional differences, some results, such as higher levels of anxiety and lower self-esteem, were no longer evident, suggesting that environmental factors associated with living in a large metropolitan area play a role in these results.
“This interpretation suggests that although comedians have a slightly different personality profile, there is little evidence of differences in rates of psychiatric symptoms or personality dysfunction, which does not support the stereotype of problematic stand-ups,” the researchers concluded.
Recent Comments